Sunday, October 25, 2020

Has Federalism in Somalia Prevented The Rise Of Dictatorship?

Dahir M Mahmoud

Monday, 18, September 2020



The only Somali constitution adopted through a universal vote was the Somali constitution of 1960 which defined the first Somali republic as an independent, sovereign, democratic and unitary republic.

Post-independence Somali leaders viewed the unitary system as an effective tool to maintain national unity, stability and economic growth. The civilian government of 1960 to 1969 was subsequently followed by a totalitarian military regime which dragged the country into a Civil War in 1991.  It also created distrust among communities and eliminated Somali nationalism and brotherhood.

To reconcile national unity and the negative outcomes of the Civil War, Somali delegations agreed to establish a federal republic to hold the country together. The federation was defined in the transitional charter 2004, and then in the provisional constitution of 2012 – “ Somalia is a federal, sovereign, and democratic republic founded on the inclusive representation of people, a  multiparty system and social justice”.

Somali people today are divided along federalist lines. Supporters argue that the federation ensures the separation of powers and prevents the rise of a dictatorial central government – whereas sceptics claim that the tribal federal system could jeopardize national unity and territorial integrity.

The elected Federal Government of 2012, ensured the expansion of federalism and created the remaining federal member states despite fierce criticism on the formation and the involvement of neighbouring countries. In early 2017, the Somali Federal Parliament (the House of People and the Upper House) elected the Somali federal president. He spearheaded a campaign to implement a strong central government, declared that there was a need to build a strong central government in his speech at the Somali National University graduation ceremony 24 June 2019. The strong central government was an option proposed in the article – The Porcupine  Dilemma: Governance and Transition in Somalia 2007.

Strong central government campaign started at federal institutions, the president and his group (NN) took control of all three branches of the federal government (Executive, Legislative and  Judiciary).  UN report on Somalia 2nd May 2018 stated that a motion of no confidence was filed against the speaker of the House of People due to rejection of attempts by the federal government to arrest and remove sitting parliamentarians.  The speaker lost his position defending the immunity of the members of the parliament.

After full control of the three branches of the federal government under the slogan “Strong central government”, the president and his group (NN) started intervention into federal member states. Federal government (FG) employed various tactics to intervene into federal member states (FMS) affairs such as corruption, manipulation of the election, deployment of the federal army without consent, use of Ethiopian  AMISOM  forces, banning air transport and exploiting the distribution of development funds.  FG and FMS  meeting in Garowe from 5 – 10 May 2019,  FMS reiterated their grievances including the lack of consultation on the key political process and federal legislation and alleged interference in state affairs. Consequently, the central government succeeded in creating dependent federal member states (Hirshabele, Galmudug and Southwest) while the other two (Jubbaland and Puntland) survived as independent regional states.

Participation of  FMS in national legislation and policymaking is based on the constitution or conventional practice. For example, in Canada, the PM meets heads of provinces as a conventional practice but in Pakistan, the federal PM is under constitutional obligation to meet chief ministers of provinces to formulate and regulate policies. Similarly, in Somalia, it is a constitutional obligation to convene an annual conference of executive heads of FG and FMS in order to discuss and agree on national unity, security, finance and information sharing- Art.51(3) of the provisional constitution.

In the middle of the FG campaign on building a strong central government, FG term comes to an end and power transfer became inevitable. Despite the FG intending to extend term-limits and manipulate elections, it is time to seek compromise with FMS. The election is not in the single list of FG powers and responsibilities enlisted in Art: 54 of the provisional constitution. Election law enacted by federal parliament and executed FMS so it is a shared responsibility. This responsibility is subject to agreement between FG and FMS. There are several points to be clarified in the agreement such as federal election body, state election body, harmonization of state election law with federal election law and implementation guidance. The Dhusamareb Electoral Consultative Conference affirms that elections are practically a responsibility between the federal government and federal member states. The central government had to reach an agreement with FMS and relinquish its orders to go to the polls. The Mogadishu agreement is evidence that the election is a joint responsibility between the federal government and FMS. The FG president declared that the federal parliament will have the final decision on the election agreement which may create further confusion on election responsibility and cause a delay.

The president knew that if the Dhusamareb conference failed, the regional governments will ensure that the state governments would still function independently due to the federal system. Thus Somali federal member states prevented dictatorial central government and dictatorship is a matter in the past (dead and buried). Somali people realised the benefit of federalism as a shield against the dictatorial central government.  



Dahir M. Mahmoud (Dawilow) is a Senior legal advisor based in London, UK.
He can be conatcted via Email: [email protected]

advertisements

 

This post first appeared on Hiiraan Online. Read the http://www.hiiraan.com/op4/2020/Sept/180041/has_federalism_in_somalia_prevented_the_rise_of_dictatorial_central_government.aspxoriginal article

Related Articles

Xuseen Macalin oo Ka Hadlay Sababta Ergadii Doorashada 2016-kii Loo Laayey, Qaarna Shabaab Isku Dhiibeen

Xuseen Macalim Maxamuud oo ah madaxa machadka Hiraal ee daraasaadka amniga oo todobaadkan qeyb ka ahaa martida barnaamijka MADASHA ee Goobjoog News ayaa ku dheeraaday amniga iyo doorashada. Mudane Xuseen ayaa sheegay in sanadkan ay soo kordheen 5 magaalo oo dheeri ah iyo mid konton ergo isaga oo intaasi raaciyey “ 2016-kii modelka heshiiska waxaa qeyb ka ahaa qaabka amniga loo wajahayo oo heshiis laga gaaray, hadda heshiiska arrintaas oo hoos uguma dhaadhicin, marka ma heshiis soo socdo oo dowladda iyo dowlad goboleedyada ka wada hadli doonaanaa, maxaa la iska maleeyey, maadaama ay waayo aragnimo hore jiro in sidii loo qaban doono”. Dhanka kale, madaxa Hiraal Xuseen Macalin ayaa kala qeybiyey ciladaha jira isaga oo yiri “Marxalad waa hawsha inta ay socoto iyo sida loo ilaalinaayo habsami u socoshada hawlaha, qeybtaas waa qeyb farsamadeeda la yaqaano, oo horay loo galay, gobol walba hawshiisa waa qabsan karaa, laakin waxaa jira qeyb kale oo amniga ah ergada amnigooda badcal doorashada, waa in qorshaha lagu daro, oo laga hadlo sida ugu qurxan ee dadkaas ineysan dacawga fursad u helin, sadadkii hore waxyaabihii la gafay ayey ka mid aheyd oo waad la socotaa in 2017, 2018 iyo 2019-kii in ergada la lalaayey ama qaar isdhiibay oo Shabaab cafis weydiistay, marka arrintaas halaga hortago”. Barnaamijka MADASHA waa todobaadle xoogga saara arrimaha siyaasadda iyo doorashada. Goobjoog News

Wasiirka Arimaha Gudaha Oo hakiyey Dhismaha Maamulka Hirshabelle

Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest WhatsApp Illo xog-ogaal ah oo magaalada Jowhar ku sugan ayaa ku warramaya in Wasiirka arrimaha gudaha Fedaraalka iyo Dib-U-Heshiisiinta Soomaaliya Gen. Mukhtaar Xuseen Afrax oo qadka Teleefanka kula hadlay Odayaasha dhaqanka Madaxweyne ku xigeenka Hirshabelle Cali Guudlaawe Xuseen iyo Wasiirka Arrimaha gudaha Hirshabelle Maxamed Cali Caadle uu ku amray in howsha ay wadaan hakiyaan mas’uuliyadda dhismaha Hirshabelle looga dambeeyo Dowladda Soomaaliya. Wasiirka ayaa intaasi ku daray in Beledweyne uu tagi doono berri oo Isniin ah si uu u ogaado tabashada reer Hiiraan ay ka qabaan qaabka loo wajahayo dhismaha Hirshabelle kaddibna jowhar uu tagi doono. Tallaabadan ayaa timid kaddib markii xalay Jowhar laga helay xog sheegeeysa in Madaxweyne ku xigeenka Hirshabelle Cali guudlaawe uu Odayaasha dhaqanka ka dalbaday in ay deg deg ku gudbiyaan liiska xildhibaanada cusub si guddi dhismaha Baarlamaanka labaad ee hirshabelle iyana ugu dhawaaqaan xildhibaanada cusub. Sikastaba tallaabadaan ay qaaday dowladda Soomaaliya ayaa ka dhigan in dhismaha hirshabelle iyo go’aanka ugu dambeeya uu yaallo Beledweyne uuna ku jiro gacanta Odayaasha dhaqanka ee tabashada qaba. Weli waxaan muuqan oo Villa Soomaaliya aysan cadeyn mowqifkeeda ku Aadan Doorashada Hirshabelle oo la sheegay in Fahad Yaasiin uu Cali Guudlaawe taageerayo si Madaxweyne unoqdo. Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest WhatsApp

Madaxweyne Muuse Biixi oo cafis u fidiyay Maxamed Cumar Carte

Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Madaxweynaha Maamulka Somaliland Muuse Biixi ayaa cafis u fidiyey Ra’iisul Wasaare ku-xigeenkii hore ee Soomaaliya Maxamed Cumar Carte oo doonaya inuu dib ugu laabto magaalada Hargeysa. Qoraal kasoo baxay Xafiiska Madaxweyne Muuse Biixi ayaa waxaa lagu sheegay in Madaxweynaha uu cafis u fidiyay Maxamed Cumar Carte, isla markaana uu tixgeliyay Codka uga yimid oo ah inuu Aabihiis oo caan ka ah Somaliland uu xanuunsan yahay.Maxamed Cumar Carte oo ka mid ahaa xildhibaanada baarlamaanka dowlada federalka ayaa la sheegay inuu iska casilay xilkaas. Cumar Carte Qaalib oo ah aabaha dhalay Maxamed Cumar Carte ayaa ku xanuusanaya magaalada Hargeysa,waxana uu hore uga soo qabtay xilal kala duwan dowladihii hore u soo maray dalka. Dhinaca kale Xisbiyada Mucaaradka Somaliland ayaa ka digay in Ra’iisul Wasaare ku-xigeenkii hore ee dalka tego Magaalada Hargeysa, iyagoo tegitaankiisa Caasimadda Somaliland shuruud uga dhigay ka tanaasulka fikirka midnimadda Soomaaliyeed. Hoos ka Akhiso Qoraalka kasoo baxay Madaxweyne Muuse Biixi. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Previous articleMusharax Madaxweyne Xasan Cali Kheyre oo gaaray dalka Turkiga

Stay Connected

20,912FansLike
2,388FollowersFollow
0SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles

Xuseen Macalin oo Ka Hadlay Sababta Ergadii Doorashada 2016-kii Loo Laayey, Qaarna Shabaab Isku Dhiibeen

Xuseen Macalim Maxamuud oo ah madaxa machadka Hiraal ee daraasaadka amniga oo todobaadkan qeyb ka ahaa martida barnaamijka MADASHA ee Goobjoog News ayaa ku dheeraaday amniga iyo doorashada. Mudane Xuseen ayaa sheegay in sanadkan ay soo kordheen 5 magaalo oo dheeri ah iyo mid konton ergo isaga oo intaasi raaciyey “ 2016-kii modelka heshiiska waxaa qeyb ka ahaa qaabka amniga loo wajahayo oo heshiis laga gaaray, hadda heshiiska arrintaas oo hoos uguma dhaadhicin, marka ma heshiis soo socdo oo dowladda iyo dowlad goboleedyada ka wada hadli doonaanaa, maxaa la iska maleeyey, maadaama ay waayo aragnimo hore jiro in sidii loo qaban doono”. Dhanka kale, madaxa Hiraal Xuseen Macalin ayaa kala qeybiyey ciladaha jira isaga oo yiri “Marxalad waa hawsha inta ay socoto iyo sida loo ilaalinaayo habsami u socoshada hawlaha, qeybtaas waa qeyb farsamadeeda la yaqaano, oo horay loo galay, gobol walba hawshiisa waa qabsan karaa, laakin waxaa jira qeyb kale oo amniga ah ergada amnigooda badcal doorashada, waa in qorshaha lagu daro, oo laga hadlo sida ugu qurxan ee dadkaas ineysan dacawga fursad u helin, sadadkii hore waxyaabihii la gafay ayey ka mid aheyd oo waad la socotaa in 2017, 2018 iyo 2019-kii in ergada la lalaayey ama qaar isdhiibay oo Shabaab cafis weydiistay, marka arrintaas halaga hortago”. Barnaamijka MADASHA waa todobaadle xoogga saara arrimaha siyaasadda iyo doorashada. Goobjoog News

Wasiirka Arimaha Gudaha Oo hakiyey Dhismaha Maamulka Hirshabelle

Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest WhatsApp Illo xog-ogaal ah oo magaalada Jowhar ku sugan ayaa ku warramaya in Wasiirka arrimaha gudaha Fedaraalka iyo Dib-U-Heshiisiinta Soomaaliya Gen. Mukhtaar Xuseen Afrax oo qadka Teleefanka kula hadlay Odayaasha dhaqanka Madaxweyne ku xigeenka Hirshabelle Cali Guudlaawe Xuseen iyo Wasiirka Arrimaha gudaha Hirshabelle Maxamed Cali Caadle uu ku amray in howsha ay wadaan hakiyaan mas’uuliyadda dhismaha Hirshabelle looga dambeeyo Dowladda Soomaaliya. Wasiirka ayaa intaasi ku daray in Beledweyne uu tagi doono berri oo Isniin ah si uu u ogaado tabashada reer Hiiraan ay ka qabaan qaabka loo wajahayo dhismaha Hirshabelle kaddibna jowhar uu tagi doono. Tallaabadan ayaa timid kaddib markii xalay Jowhar laga helay xog sheegeeysa in Madaxweyne ku xigeenka Hirshabelle Cali guudlaawe uu Odayaasha dhaqanka ka dalbaday in ay deg deg ku gudbiyaan liiska xildhibaanada cusub si guddi dhismaha Baarlamaanka labaad ee hirshabelle iyana ugu dhawaaqaan xildhibaanada cusub. Sikastaba tallaabadaan ay qaaday dowladda Soomaaliya ayaa ka dhigan in dhismaha hirshabelle iyo go’aanka ugu dambeeya uu yaallo Beledweyne uuna ku jiro gacanta Odayaasha dhaqanka ee tabashada qaba. Weli waxaan muuqan oo Villa Soomaaliya aysan cadeyn mowqifkeeda ku Aadan Doorashada Hirshabelle oo la sheegay in Fahad Yaasiin uu Cali Guudlaawe taageerayo si Madaxweyne unoqdo. Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest WhatsApp

Madaxweyne Muuse Biixi oo cafis u fidiyay Maxamed Cumar Carte

Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Madaxweynaha Maamulka Somaliland Muuse Biixi ayaa cafis u fidiyey Ra’iisul Wasaare ku-xigeenkii hore ee Soomaaliya Maxamed Cumar Carte oo doonaya inuu dib ugu laabto magaalada Hargeysa. Qoraal kasoo baxay Xafiiska Madaxweyne Muuse Biixi ayaa waxaa lagu sheegay in Madaxweynaha uu cafis u fidiyay Maxamed Cumar Carte, isla markaana uu tixgeliyay Codka uga yimid oo ah inuu Aabihiis oo caan ka ah Somaliland uu xanuunsan yahay.Maxamed Cumar Carte oo ka mid ahaa xildhibaanada baarlamaanka dowlada federalka ayaa la sheegay inuu iska casilay xilkaas. Cumar Carte Qaalib oo ah aabaha dhalay Maxamed Cumar Carte ayaa ku xanuusanaya magaalada Hargeysa,waxana uu hore uga soo qabtay xilal kala duwan dowladihii hore u soo maray dalka. Dhinaca kale Xisbiyada Mucaaradka Somaliland ayaa ka digay in Ra’iisul Wasaare ku-xigeenkii hore ee dalka tego Magaalada Hargeysa, iyagoo tegitaankiisa Caasimadda Somaliland shuruud uga dhigay ka tanaasulka fikirka midnimadda Soomaaliyeed. Hoos ka Akhiso Qoraalka kasoo baxay Madaxweyne Muuse Biixi. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Previous articleMusharax Madaxweyne Xasan Cali Kheyre oo gaaray dalka Turkiga

Musharax Madaxweyne Xasan Cali Kheyre oo gaaray dalka Turkiga

Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Ra’iisul Wasaarihii hore ee Soomaaliya ahna Musharax Madaxweyne Xasan Cali Khayre ayaa maanta gaaray magaalada Istambul ee dalka Turkiga, isagoo si heer sare ah loogu soo dhaweeyay halkaas. Xasan Cali Kheyre oo maalmihii la soo dhaafay dardar ku bilaabay ololihiisa doorashada tartanka Madaxweynaha Soomaaliya 2021 ayaa safaro ku tagay dalalka Kenya iyo Jabuuti. Waa Musharaxa kaliya ee Ololihiisa si weyn looga dareemay dalka gudihiisa iyo dibaddiisa, tan iyo markii bishii hore uu baraha bulshada ee Twitter-ka iyo Facebook ku shaaciyay inuu yahay Musharax u taagan xilka Madaxweynaha Soomaaliya Xasan Khayre oo ay wehliyaan saraakiil kamid ah kooxdiisa ololaha ayaa lasoo warinayaa inuu la kulmayo madaxda dalka, bulshada Soomaaliyeed ee ku nool dalka Turkiga iyo qurba joog kale dalalka Yurub uga timid inay la kulmaan. xasan cali kheyre oo gaaray Istambul Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Previous articleXukun lagu ridey rag lagu eedeeyay inay ku lug lahaayeen weerarkii Xabsiga Dhexe Next articleMadaxweyne Muuse Biixi oo cafis u fidiyay Maxamed Cumar Carte

RW ku-xigeenkii hore ee Somalia oo ka degay Hargeysa ka dib cafis uu u fidiyey Muuse Biixi

Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest WhatsApp - Advertisement - Ra’iisul Wasaare ku-xigeenkii hore ee Soomaaliya Maxamed Cumar Carte Qaalib ayaa gaaray Magaalada Hargeysa ee xarunta Maamulka Somaliland, halkaasoo si weyn loogu dhaweeyay. Maxamed Cumar Carte ayaa waxaa Garoonka dayuuradaha Cigaal ku soo dhoweeyey Mas’uuliyiin ka tirsan Somaliland, siyaasiyiin iyo qaar kamid ah eheladiisa oo ay muddo dheer ugu dambeysay. Wararka ayaa sheegaya in RW ku-xigeenkii hore uu iska casilay kursigiisii xildhibaanimo ee baarlamanka Somalia, uuna ka tanaasulay fekerkii Soomaaliweyn. Madaxweynaha Somaliland Muuse Biixi ayaa soo saaray booqashada ka hor qoraal uu cafis ugu fidiyey Maxamed Cumar Carte ka dib xiriir dhexmaray, taasoo suuragelisay inuu ku laabto Hargeysa. Ra’iisul Wasaare ku-xigeenkii hore ee Soomaaliya Maxamed Cumar Carte Qaalib oo muddo dheer ku sugnaa Muqdisho ayaa la sheegay iney arrintan ku qasabtay aabihii Cumar Carte Qaalib oo ku xanuunsanaya Hargeysa, kaasoo muddo sanado ah aysan is arkin Hoos ka akhriso qoraalka Muuse Biixi cafiska ugu fidiyey Maxamed Cumar Carte Qaalib:- Xafiiska Shabakada Allbanaadir.comMuqdisho [email protected] - Advertisement - Facebook Twitter Google+ Pinterest WhatsApp Previous article(Sawirro) Deni furay kalfadhiga Baarlamanka Puntland, kana hadlay arrimo xasaasi ah

This post first appeared on Hiiraan Online. Read the http://www.hiiraan.com/op4/2020/Sept/180041/has_federalism_in_somalia_prevented_the_rise_of_dictatorial_central_government.aspxoriginal article