Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Ethiopia: Splitting Southern Nations region into four can promote peace

Ethiopia: Splitting Southern Nations region into four can promote peace

For more than two decades, the question of statehood formation has been raised by identiy-based zones in the Southern Nations Nationalities and Peoples’ Regional State (SNNPRS).

In particular, the issue proliferated after the collapse of the authority of the Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) and the arrival of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed in 2018. Consequently, the question has been raised the Wolayta, Keffa, Gurage, Gamo, Gofa, and Sidama ethnic groups.

Given this political context and the House of Federation’s approval this week of the zonal councils of Dawro, Bench Sheko, Sheka, West Omo and Keffa’s request to form a single region, it is important to assess this new approach to regional statehood in Ethiopia.

Fresh thinking

During Ethiopia’s last transition, Southern Nations Nationalities and People’s Regional State (SNNPRS) was formed by merging five districts following regional council elections in 1992. Furthermore, as a region of more than 56 ‘nationalities, it is one of the largest in Ethiopia, accounting for more than 10 percent of the country’s area and almost a fifth of the population.

Until Sidama established its own region, SNNPRS was divided into 13 zones, 133 and 3,512 kebeles. While the Sidama are the largest ethnic group in the region, each ethnicity is the majority in its administrative zone in terms of number and there are also minorities.

Given the prevalence of statehood requests, a team was established by the now-defunct Southern Ethiopian People Democratic Movement (SEPDM) to conduct a “scientific study” on how to handle several claims for regional statehood. After seven months, the team presented its findings and the following options to the SEPDM Executive Committee:

  • Proceed with the existing region without any change, or;
  • Except for the Sidama, organize the remaining “nations, nationalities and peoples” into one region, or;
  • Not entertain questions of region formation for some time.

Nevertheless, there was not widespread acceptance of any of the above recommended solutions. Given this lack of consensus, another option is actively being considered.

The idea is to re-organize the SNNPRS into four regions, including Sidama, and one Special Zone. This option emerged after the December 2019 establishment of Prosperity Party and is mainly propagated by the national peace ambassadors or Yeselam Ambasaderoch Committee (a committee established under the Office of the Prime Minster to investigate the autonomy demands).

The Committee, the Prime Minister, and the House of Federation (HoF) have subsequently held discussions with representatives from SNNPRS zones and weredas on the issue. As a result, the Committee indicated that there is an agreement to re-organize SNNPRS into four regions and one Special Zone.

Based on the settlement patterns and the consent of the people concerned, this agreement is ready to be submitted to the HoF. The upper house of parliament is expected to reply within 30 days of its acceptance. The suggested regions, one of which has been accepted already, are:

  1. Damotic/Omotic Region: Gamo, Gofa, Konso, South Omo, Derashe, Burji, Amaro, Wolayta, Basketo.
  2. Northern and Central Region: Hadiya, Kembata, Tembaro, Silte, Gurage, Yem, Alaba.
  3. South West Region: Keffa, Sheka, Bench Sheko, Dawro, Konta, West Omo and Konta.
  4. Sidama Region: Sidama, Gedeo.

While Gedeo is to become a Special Zone, it has not been not decided which region it will be part of. Gedeo Special Zone would then have the rights to use its language and approve budgets, while still being governed by regional laws. Alternatively, the Committee recommended the formation of a new region that encompasses Gedeo Special Zone, and the Burji and Amaro people’s administrative districts. Nonetheless, such an option does not appear to be accepted by the people.

So far the Wolayta members of SNNPRS State Council have strongly opposed the organization of the Wolayta under the Omotic Region as they want their own region like the Sidama. Equally, other members of the Omotic Region like the Gamo, Gofa have shown dissatisfaction. As a result, the Prime Minister and members of the Peace Ambassadors Committee have recently gone to the area to discuss and seek solutions.

On the other hand, on 30 September, the zonal councils of Keffa, Sheka, Bench Sheko, Dawro, West Omo including with Konta Special Woreda have unanimously agreed to integrate in to a single region. With the HoF recently approving this approach and requesting the National Electoral Board of Ethiopia to conduct a referendum, this new region will probably be called the South West Region.

The promise

The Ethiopian federation contains constitutional provisions that grant autonomy upon request. While the regional states of Amhara, Oromia, Tigray, Afar and Somalia have dominant nationality groups, the others are multi-ethnic. For example, Benishangul-Gumuz has Berta, Shinasha, Gumuz, Mao and Komo nationalities. Gambella has Nuer, Anuak and Mezenger, and Harari has Oromo, Amhara and Gurage. However, the case of the SNNPRS is peculiar, as the region contains so many groups.

Since the introduction of the federal system in 1995, there have been frequent questions for region-formation by SNNPRS groups and also regular and deadly conflicts in the region. There are several factors that brought this about. One is the failure to find an administrative structure that works for the multiple SNNPRS groups. The current re-structuring will create multicultural regions, even if there is no dominant group, which may reduce conflict, and the claim for independent regions, at least for a while, in most zones.

Another positive aspect of this new arrangement is that it will address some of the administrative problems that stem from the current arrangement. Given that federalism seeks to devolve public administration, if the geographical distance between the government and the people grows, the more difficult it is for the people to make their voices heard, and for rulers to understand their needs, aspirations, and priorities.

Federalism helps to resolve this problem, as it enables substantive powers to be exercised at the regional or sub-regional levels, giving people greater opportunities to exercise democratic control over public administration, resource utilization, policy adoption and law enforcement. For instance, it takes more than three days to go to the regional seat of Hawassa from the most peripheral weredas of Sheka and Bench Sheko zones.

Furthermore, by lumping all ethnic groups together, the existing arrangement does not adequately manage demographic factors, settlement patterns, languages and the consent of the population during region formation, as enshrined under article 46(2) of the federal constitution. In contrast, re-structuring the region into four regions (as recommended by the Committee) will create cluster of communities that have a similar way of life and settlement pattern.

For instance, if we look at the proposed South West Region, while the languages spoken by the Keffa and Sheka people are very similar  except for pronunciation, the two languages (Dawrigna) spoken by the Dawro/Konta people also share words with similar meanings.

The challenge

The federal constitution states that “All sovereign power resides in the Nations, Nationalities, and Peoples of Ethiopia.” In this light, Article 39 grants nations, nationalities and peoples the right to self-determination including secession. At the same time, it further entitles every group the right to establish their own region under Article 47(2). Hence we can imagine 56 regions springing out of the fragmenting SNNPRS. Such extreme fragmentation would further complicate the political, economic, and social state of the southern part of the federation.

Another challenge that the region could face is the issue of minorities. For instance, in the proposed South West Region, which encompasses the major ethnic groups of Keffa, Sheka, Bench, Sheko, and Dawro, there are the Menja people, a minority related to the Keffa.

While federalism can provide minorities a certain level of recognition and autonomy, it can also expose them to discrimination and oppression. This is particularly the case if these minority groups were not part of the deliberations that established new arrangements, as their interests may not be represented.

It is important to also note that, since the idea to restructure the SNNPRS was tabled, there has been competition for the capital city of regional states. This struggle could potentially become a major obstacle to the process.

Finally, the fact that there could be more than four regions could pose a challenge to effective public administration, as the new regional governments may lack the requisite human and financial resources. This risks overburdening weak newly established institutions with demands that they cannot meet and so could cause disappointment, mistrust, and discontent among the public.

Related Articles

Bililiqada Ceerigaabo ka socota

20th October 2020  admin  Category : Nashqadaynta ay Hartiga Ceerigaabo u baahan yihiin oo Isaaqa reer Ceerigaabo degani ayna u baahnayn waa bililiqo iyo koox isu arkay inay ku guulaysteen dagaalkii beelaha ee gobolka Sanaag. Nimakan Cagfta gelinaya qaar ka mid ah waa ku iibsaday Dhismayaashii iyo iyo dawladdii Kcaanka dhisay oo guryo kaga iibsaday dalka Turkiga [embedded content]

Warqad furan Ku socoda madaxweynaha Somaliland

October 20, 2020 | Published by: yaska Warqad furan Ka timid abdisalaan mohamoud Ku socoda madaxweynaha qaranka Mawduuca Odweyne Mudane madaxweyne kusoo dhawoow caasimada Gobolka Daadmadheedh ee Odweine xarunta shidaalka iyo khayraad ka dalka Tan iyo intii aad xilka madaxweyne aad Talada wadanka qabatay waa markii labaad ee aad soo booqato gobolka waa arin muujinaysa dadaalka iyo juhdiga wadanka ku doonayso Inaad xogogaal noqodo baahiyaha aasaasiga ee gobolka Mudane madaxweyne mudadii aad xilka haysay siyaasadaada waxqabad ee gobolka Daadmadheedh waa kaaga mahad celinaynaa waxqabad ka muuqda ee aad ka hirgalisay odweiwe A.hirgelinta dhameystira Banka dhexe ee masuulka kaaga yahay Gudoomiye Cali Ibrahim Jama Baqdaadi oo ka hirgaliey dhisitaanka banki weyn oo ah rugunada dawladnimada kana soo baxey waajibadka qaran B.maxkamadii gobolka la dhameystiran C. Jeelki weynaa oo la dhisayo Iyo dadaalo badan oo aad muujisay oo iyana socda Mudane madaxweyne Baahiyaha aasaasiga ee u baahan Inaad u guur gasho 1. Odweine waa xuduntii xoolaha shidaalka iyo beeraha waa gobolka ugu balaadhan istaraatiji ahaan iyo baaxad ahaan ba madaxweyne Odweine cashuurteeda burco iyo hargeisa ayay ku dhacaan awood umalaha inay neefka xoolaha cashuurato oo ay u madaxbanaanaato waxaa dabar ku ah xeerka baarlamaanka oo Xanibay cashuurtii gobolka curyaamin weyna ku ah gobolka madaxweyne arinta wax ka qabo 2. Madaxweyne noqo mid hirgeliya balantii aad reer Oodweyne aad kaga farxisay Inaad wadada burco odweyne iyo hargeisa dhagax dhigto dhisi doonto taas oo aan odhan karo waxaad timid wakhtigeedi waa wado wax ku ool ah dhaqaale ahaan iyo dawlad ahaan ba waana halwable uu qarankani tebayo wadadan waxaa filayaa Inaad ka dhabayn doonto madaxweyne 3.madaxweyne waa Inaad daadajisaa nidaamka dawladnimada iyo adeega dawlada sidaad imikaba aad u wado dhaqaale ahaan maamul ahaan iyo dad ahaan waa nidaamka Dawadnima hargeisa la dhaafiyo goob kasta waa Inaad gaadhsiisa adeega dawladeed. 4. Madaxweyne masuuliyiinta gobolka metala kula xisaabtan waxay umada u qabteen uma baahnin masuul kursiga Oodweyne iskaga fadhiya waxii loo igmadeyna aan qaban uu guur galista odweyne masuul kasta a inuu xafiiskiisu ka shaqeeyo waxay ku tusi doontaa cida wax qabatay iyo kuwa aan waxba qaban si fudud baad u ogaan doonta 5. Baahiyaha aasaasiga ee gobolka waa kuwo aad u tiro badan Marka laga tago masuuliyiin faro ku Tiris ah oo shaqadooda kasoo baxay soona gaadhsiiyay adeegii dawladnimada ee aad u igmadey taasna aad ku abaalmariso wax qabad ka bulshada u qabteen kuwa aan wax qabana aad kula xisaabtando waxay wax uga qaban waayeen shaqadii dawlada ay u hayeen bulshada ugu celin waayeen 6. Mudane madaxweyne gobolka doorkii badhasaabnimada ayuu 7. Madaxweyne wasaaradaha gobolka inta badan xafiisyo kuma laha Marka laga tago wasaarada kooban 8.madaxweyne gobolka wuxuu baahanyahay kastamkii in loo sameeyo si gobolka ula jaanqaado gobolada kale dalka taas oo ka qayb qaadanaysa Koboca dhaqaale ee odweyne tabayo iyo dalkaba socdaalkaaga waxay marag madoon u tahay sida aad ugu dafaxeydan tahay dalka Inaad meel fiican gaadhsiiso mudane madaxweyne waxaa filayaa Inaad Baahiyaha a wax ka qaban doonto waxna ka bedel I doonto. Wabilaahi tawfiiq. LA WADAAG ASXAABTAADA

Stay Connected

20,875FansLike
2,388FollowersFollow
0SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles

Bililiqada Ceerigaabo ka socota

20th October 2020  admin  Category : Nashqadaynta ay Hartiga Ceerigaabo u baahan yihiin oo Isaaqa reer Ceerigaabo degani ayna u baahnayn waa bililiqo iyo koox isu arkay inay ku guulaysteen dagaalkii beelaha ee gobolka Sanaag. Nimakan Cagfta gelinaya qaar ka mid ah waa ku iibsaday Dhismayaashii iyo iyo dawladdii Kcaanka dhisay oo guryo kaga iibsaday dalka Turkiga [embedded content]

Warqad furan Ku socoda madaxweynaha Somaliland

October 20, 2020 | Published by: yaska Warqad furan Ka timid abdisalaan mohamoud Ku socoda madaxweynaha qaranka Mawduuca Odweyne Mudane madaxweyne kusoo dhawoow caasimada Gobolka Daadmadheedh ee Odweine xarunta shidaalka iyo khayraad ka dalka Tan iyo intii aad xilka madaxweyne aad Talada wadanka qabatay waa markii labaad ee aad soo booqato gobolka waa arin muujinaysa dadaalka iyo juhdiga wadanka ku doonayso Inaad xogogaal noqodo baahiyaha aasaasiga ee gobolka Mudane madaxweyne mudadii aad xilka haysay siyaasadaada waxqabad ee gobolka Daadmadheedh waa kaaga mahad celinaynaa waxqabad ka muuqda ee aad ka hirgalisay odweiwe A.hirgelinta dhameystira Banka dhexe ee masuulka kaaga yahay Gudoomiye Cali Ibrahim Jama Baqdaadi oo ka hirgaliey dhisitaanka banki weyn oo ah rugunada dawladnimada kana soo baxey waajibadka qaran B.maxkamadii gobolka la dhameystiran C. Jeelki weynaa oo la dhisayo Iyo dadaalo badan oo aad muujisay oo iyana socda Mudane madaxweyne Baahiyaha aasaasiga ee u baahan Inaad u guur gasho 1. Odweine waa xuduntii xoolaha shidaalka iyo beeraha waa gobolka ugu balaadhan istaraatiji ahaan iyo baaxad ahaan ba madaxweyne Odweine cashuurteeda burco iyo hargeisa ayay ku dhacaan awood umalaha inay neefka xoolaha cashuurato oo ay u madaxbanaanaato waxaa dabar ku ah xeerka baarlamaanka oo Xanibay cashuurtii gobolka curyaamin weyna ku ah gobolka madaxweyne arinta wax ka qabo 2. Madaxweyne noqo mid hirgeliya balantii aad reer Oodweyne aad kaga farxisay Inaad wadada burco odweyne iyo hargeisa dhagax dhigto dhisi doonto taas oo aan odhan karo waxaad timid wakhtigeedi waa wado wax ku ool ah dhaqaale ahaan iyo dawlad ahaan ba waana halwable uu qarankani tebayo wadadan waxaa filayaa Inaad ka dhabayn doonto madaxweyne 3.madaxweyne waa Inaad daadajisaa nidaamka dawladnimada iyo adeega dawlada sidaad imikaba aad u wado dhaqaale ahaan maamul ahaan iyo dad ahaan waa nidaamka Dawadnima hargeisa la dhaafiyo goob kasta waa Inaad gaadhsiisa adeega dawladeed. 4. Madaxweyne masuuliyiinta gobolka metala kula xisaabtan waxay umada u qabteen uma baahnin masuul kursiga Oodweyne iskaga fadhiya waxii loo igmadeyna aan qaban uu guur galista odweyne masuul kasta a inuu xafiiskiisu ka shaqeeyo waxay ku tusi doontaa cida wax qabatay iyo kuwa aan waxba qaban si fudud baad u ogaan doonta 5. Baahiyaha aasaasiga ee gobolka waa kuwo aad u tiro badan Marka laga tago masuuliyiin faro ku Tiris ah oo shaqadooda kasoo baxay soona gaadhsiiyay adeegii dawladnimada ee aad u igmadey taasna aad ku abaalmariso wax qabad ka bulshada u qabteen kuwa aan wax qabana aad kula xisaabtando waxay wax uga qaban waayeen shaqadii dawlada ay u hayeen bulshada ugu celin waayeen 6. Mudane madaxweyne gobolka doorkii badhasaabnimada ayuu 7. Madaxweyne wasaaradaha gobolka inta badan xafiisyo kuma laha Marka laga tago wasaarada kooban 8.madaxweyne gobolka wuxuu baahanyahay kastamkii in loo sameeyo si gobolka ula jaanqaado gobolada kale dalka taas oo ka qayb qaadanaysa Koboca dhaqaale ee odweyne tabayo iyo dalkaba socdaalkaaga waxay marag madoon u tahay sida aad ugu dafaxeydan tahay dalka Inaad meel fiican gaadhsiiso mudane madaxweyne waxaa filayaa Inaad Baahiyaha a wax ka qaban doonto waxna ka bedel I doonto. Wabilaahi tawfiiq. LA WADAAG ASXAABTAADA

Maxaysatada Siyaasadda Soomaalilaan. Ujeeddo badan.

October 20, 2020 | Published by: yaska Madaxdii dowladda waxaa isha ku haya dhalinyaro wax basaasa oo u dhigma xisaabiyaha idman oo aan libiqsanayn, waa sidii xukuumaddii kacaanka, madaxdu way la sii jeestaan marka ay xanjo afka gelinayaan. Inamadu waxba ma maqlaan, kursiga kama kacaan iyaga oo wax qooraansanaya mooyee, waxaa lagu xantaa ‘ yaryarka dalbaha leh.’ Odaygan magiciisu waa jab Libaax, xisbigii uu ka tirsanaa wuxuu kala daatay, markii lagaga adkaaday doorashadii ugu dambeysey ee uu xil qabtay. Meesha wuxuu u joogaa in uu hor fadhiyo xisbiga ay beeshiisa iyo isaga laftiisu taageero ku filan guusha madaxtooyada u waayeen doorashadii u dambeysey. Hore wuxuu u lug gooyey xisbigii uu kula shuraakoobey laandheerenimada iyo danahiisa shakhsi. Inkasta oo ay jiraan faq iyo balan hoose oo uu naftiisa la galay, hadana Odayga wataa, weli ma Indho darayn, wuxuuna si foojigan u il baadinayaa dhaqdhaqaaqiisa iyo dhuumashooyinkiisaba. Is aaminku wuxuu noqday sheeko iyo beri. Waxaa jirta warqad cinwaan looga dhigo “Madaxweynaha oo diyaarinaya isku shaandhayn golaha xukuummadda” waxay soo baxdaa dhowrkii biloodba mar, waxayna soo toosisaa asxaabta godka ee rajo dhigtay, waxayse ku dambaysaa in dhowr ma quuste sawirka lagu buuxsado dabadeedna la fasaxo. Ujeeddada loo kala wado Maxamed iyo Maxamuud, waa sidii loo kala irdhayn lahaa is ogosha labada bahood ee ay wadajirkooda wax ku noqon lahaayeen, mid waxaa loo qoondeeyey sidii loo bari lahaa badhaq nugeyl aan suurto gal ahayn, iyadoo loo soo marayo hogaanka Socdaalka iyo Sirdoonka qaranka, kan kalena waxay bishu hortiisa iman, marka hoggaamiyihiisu cid u codaysaba waayo. Dadweynuhu way ka daaleen maamul aan hal abuur lahayn, oo hoggaan ciidan leh, kolkii horeba waxaa lagu liqay arrin dhaqan iyo balan la fulinayey. Badheedhaha shacabku wuxuu soo afjari doonaa, taariikhda Soomaalilaan shantii sanaddood ee abid Askari xukumo. Ninkan Inanta dhulka ku haysta, ee marka guddi xaqiiqo raadin ah la soo diraba, guriga kale ee waddada soo galay tusaya, waa nin Diinta la isku sawiro iyo khiyaanada ku cirraystay, Shiikh Khaliil baa la dhacay Muslimnimada ka muuqata, kaaga daranne macangegnimo, shan nin waddada ugama kaco, waaba kii oo gardarada garab u helay. Waanu iska aamusi lahayn, haddii uu magaalada noogu samayn lahaa calaamad qudha oo badhtamaha Burco ama waddada Howdka ishaaraysa ama hadduu tobonaanka haldoor ee reer Togdheer uu si uun u weyneyn lahaa, inay halkani tahay magaaladoodii, si ay dhalinyarada hamigooda u koriso. Tolow miyaanay arkayn hebelada iyaga oo aan filayn, diyaarna ahayn, ka hoydey adduunka, iyaga oo aan cidina u sii digin. Gafanuhu himiladiisa ma ku gaadhayaa kala guridda Maxamed iyo Muuse? Ma ku guulaysan karaa isagoo raacaya qaaciidada macalinkiisu u soo dhiibey? Maya. Labadii Xisbi mucaarad oo midba kan kale ka xigsanayo xukuumadda, si murashaxoodu ugu xigo xilka madaxtinimadda ama aan xisbigoodu ugu soo bixi waayin Ururada haddii la furo. Waxba kama ay korodhsan, kal hore iyo farsamooyinkii Kulmiyihii hore. Mucaarad kulul ayaa guuleysta, la isma baryo, axsaanna ma jiro Siyaasadda. Waxaan amaanayaa siyaasiyiinta C Geeljire, Xirsi Cali iyo C Daamur. Waddada Oodweyne waxay ka hir geli weydey koox fahmo yar, munaafaqnimo badan, oo aaminsan, haddii la isku xidho Burco, Oodweyne iyo Hargeysa, in degmada Shiikh iyo inta sii xigta Berbera ay ka lumayso fursado dhaqaale, iyaga oo aqoon gaabni garan la’, in aan Berbera marnaba looga baqayn in ay kobocdo oo barwaaqaysato. Sidee ayay reer Soomaalilaan u aaminayaan wax wada lahaansho? haddii Muwaadinka ka yimaadda Sool ama Sanaag lagu kadeedo safarrada ay ku tegayaan Caasimadda dalka, haddii hay’adaha amnigu ay soo jactediyaan, joogsiga Bari ee magaalada Shiikhna cago jugleyn iyo baadhasho loogu daro, dad wax wada leh tacadigaasi miyuu qabtaa? Hadday wada eexo tahay, hadday dabin aasan tahay, Shil iyo wada eeso tahay, hadday wada aano tahay, Hadday agaraa dam tahay, addoonsigu diin u yahay, Hadday orgobbaysan tahay, iimaanku ka qoomanyahay, Hadday abnawaasad tahay, afduub iyo beeno tahay, Hadday wada aniga tahay, siyaasadi aabe ma leh. Waa mar kale, maansadii Awaal tiris iyo filasoof Hadraawi. . Bashiir Tarabbi Oogle, Caynaba, Soomaalilaan. LA WADAAG ASXAABTAADA