Tuesday, November 24, 2020

Debunking The Top Five Fake News Narratives About Nagorno-Karabakh

Debunking The Top Five Fake News Narratives About Nagorno-Karabakh

This weekend’s resumption of hostilities in Nagorno-Karabakh has led to an explosion of fake news narratives about the conflict, hence the reason for writing this piece in order to debunk the top five ones that have since proliferated across the Alt-Media Community.

mN gzyJK Debunking The Top Five Fake News Narratives About Nagorno-Karabakh
Andrew Korybko American political analyst

Nagorno-Karabakh is back in the news after this weekend’s resumption of hostilities. The author wrote about the latest clashes in his piece about how “Azerbaijan’s Counteroffensive Is Legal But Might Inadvertently Spiral Out Of Control”, which also cites three recent analyses from over the summer that were published after the clashes during that time. All four articles are important to read in order to obtain a deeper understanding of this complex conflict’s background and contemporary context. The present piece, however, focuses solely on debunking the top five fake news narratives that have proliferated across the Alt-Media Community about this issue. Each one begins with a paraphrased summary of the false claim in question, which is then concisely debunked. Without further ado, here are the five most popular fake news claims about this conflict:

1. “Nagorno-Karabakh Is Armenian”

Most of the inhabitants of Azerbaijan’s former Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast are ethnic Armenians who aspired to separate from their country in order to join their nearby titular nation in the last days of the Old Cold War. The resultant conflict that this sparked led to the region’s occupation by the Armenian Armed Forces as well as the occupation of some of the surrounding environs that were never originally part of the former autonomous oblast in question. To this day, not a single country in the world — Armenia included — officially recognizes Nagorno-Karabakh as “independent”, though Armenian Prime Minister Pashinyan hinted on Sunday that he might consider doing so. Nevertheless, as it presently stands at the time of writing, there is unanimous acknowledgement in the international community of the fact that Nagorno-Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan despite being mostly inhabited by ethnic Armenians.

2. “Azerbaijan Started An Illegal War Of Aggression Against Armenia”

Four UNSC Resolutions (822853874884) have been passed demanding that Armenia withdraw its military forces from Azerbaijan, which it refuses to do to this day. Armenia is therefore the internationally recognized aggressor state in this conflict which continues to occupy its neighbor’s territory. Azerbaijan has the UN-enshrined legal right to defend itself and remove foreign military forces from its land. Although Armenia and Azerbaijan accuse one another of provoking the latest round of violence, it’s irrelevant who actually fired the first shot this time since there’s no question that Armenia is the occupying force on internationally recognized Azerbaijani territory. The truth is that Armenia is the one that started an illegal war of aggression against Azerbaijan decades ago, though its proponents portray it as a “humanitarian intervention”. Although everyone is entitled to their own opinion, the indisputable fact is that the UNSC doesn’t agree with Armenia’s version.

3. “Russia Will Defend The Armenian Forces In Nagorno-Karabakh”

Russia and Armenia are mutual defense allies through the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), but Moscow doesn’t recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as anything other than Azerbaijani territory. Its security guarantees are therefore limited only to protecting internationally recognized Armenian territory from foreign aggression, not intervening in Nagorno-Karabakh. It shouldn’t be forgotten that Russia is also a member of the same UNSC which voted four separate times to demand Armenia’s withdrawal from Azerbaijani territory. The CSTO is therefore only relevant insofar as serving as a deterrent to Turkish military intervention against Armenia in Azerbaijan’s support or the scenario of Azerbaijan attacking internationally recognized Armenian territory as part of its counteroffensive. Even then, however, Ankara and Baku can argue that they were taking preemptive action to stop Armenian aggression against their own territories, thus creating a legal dilemma for Moscow.

4. “Turkey Provoked The Latest Hostilities As Part Of Its Neo-Ottoman Strategy”

There’s no doubt that Turkey has become much more regionally assertive over the past decade through what many have described as its “Neo-Ottoman strategy”, but the country is already caught up in such a wide range of conflicts at the moment (Iraq, Syria, Cyprus, Greece, Libya) that it doesn’t have any interest in getting involved in another one. This is even more so the case when considering that Armenia is Russia’s CSTO ally and that the worst-case scenario involves an Armenian-Azerbaijani war becoming a CSTO-NATO proxy war or even a direct one. Turkey is also close strategic partners with Russia nowadays despite occasional differences of approach to some regional issues such as Syria and Libya. They cooperate real closely on military-technical issues such as the S-400s and energy ones like Turkish Stream. Jeopardizing this relationship and risking the worst-case scenario of a CSTO-NATO war just for the sake of regaining imperial-era glory is irrational.

5. “Azerbaijan Is An Israeli Ally So All Anti-Zionists Should Support Armenia”

Azerbaijan sells energy to “Israel” and also purchases military equipment from it, but Armenia is also on pretty good terms with the self-professed “Jewish State”. In fact, it can be argued (though importantly without endorsing it) that Azerbaijan has a more balanced relationship with “Israel” than Armenia does. After all, Armenia recently opened an embassy there despite previously promising not to ever do so unless “Israel” recognized the events that Armenia and a few dozen other countries across the world including Russia regard as the “Armenian Genocide”. Yerevan reversed its own prior policy in this respect even though it didn’t receive anything tangible in return, thus making Tel Aviv the indisputably dominant partner in that relationship. Armenia submitted to “Israel” so as to pave the way for their influential lobbyists partnering with one another as they assemble a united anti-Turkish front, but it comes off as desperate and definitely isn’t “anti-Zionist”.

——————–

Taking into account the author’s debunking of the top five fake news narratives about Nagorno-Karabakh, it’s clear that an intense infowar is being waged by Armenia’s supporters to denigrate Azerbaijan in the eyes of the Alt-Media Community. Although mostly ethnically Armenian, the region in question is legally Azerbaijani, and the UNSC has called on Armenia to withdraw from this territory and the occupied surrounding regions on four occasions. Russia doesn’t support the armed Armenian separatists there, and Turkey isn’t meddling in this matter either. Both want peace, not war. As for who anti-Zionists should support, neither Azerbaijan nor Armenia meet that ideological criteria as both are partnered with “Israel” to differing extents. In conclusion, everyone is entitled to their own views on this matter, but no one should spread false narratives about it.

Related Articles

Dhageyso : – Cabdi Farax Juxa oo ka waramaaya Taariikh nololeedkii General Khaliif Ciise Mudan

Wasiirkii hore ee Arimaha Gudaha Dawlada Fedearaalka Somaaliyeed Halgame Cabdi Farax Juxa ayaa warbaahinta uga waramay maanta Taariikh nololeedkii Allaah ha u naxariistee Generaal Khaliif Ciise Mudan oo maanta ku geeriyooday Dalka Turkey.Halkan ka dhageyso Juxa iyo Taariikh nololeedka marxuumka :

Xog: Qoor Qoor oo aqbalay dalabkii musharaxiinta balse ku xiray hal shardi

Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Linkedin Email Print Viber Muqdisho (Caasimada Online) – Madaxweynaha Maamulka Galmudug Axmed Cabdi Kaariye Qoor Qoor, ayaa kulan uu habeen hore la qaatay qaar ka mid ah musharaxiinta xilka Madaxweynaha Soomaaliya, ku ballan qaaday fulinta qodob ay cabasho ka qabeen oo ku aadan guddiyada doorashada. Sida ay ogaatay Caasimada Online, madaxweyne Qoor Qoor ayaa musharaxiinta ka aqbalay inuu badalo guddiga doorashada xubnaha ku jira qaarkood, balse waxa uu sharuud kaga dhigay in marka hore ay beddalaan maamullada kale ee dalka. “Waa naga aqbalay inuu beddalo dadka qaar ee guddiga ku jira balse waxa uu diiday inuu bilaabo isagoo naga codsaday in marka aan ka keeno maamulada kale,” ayuu yiri mid kamid ah musharaxiintii la kulmay Madaxweyne Qoor Qoor, oo la hadlay Caasimada Online. Kulankaan ayaa daba socday kulan kale oo laba habeen ka hor ka dhacay guriga Madaxweynihii hore ee Soomaaliya Xasan Sheekh Maxamuud waxaana la aaminsan yahay in Qoor Qoor dhab ka aheyn balanqaadkii uu xalay sameeyay. Shuruuddan ayaa xubnaha qaar ay ku macneeyeen mid adag, oo Qoor Qoor uga gol leeyahay inuu isaga aamuso, oo aysan daacad ka ahayn. Qoor Qoor ayaa markii la doortay, inkasta la xajinayey Villa Somalia, la rumeysnaa inuu mararka qaar yeelan doono dhiiranaan uu kaligiis go’aan ku qaato, hase yeeshee taas waxay noqotay mid lagu hungoobay. Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Linkedin Email Print Viber

Miyuu Mohamed Salah Ku Bilaaban Doonaa Kulanka Atalanta? Jurgen Klopp Ayaa Ka Jawaabay.

Tababaraha Kooxda Liverpool ee Jurgen Klopp ayaa xaqiijiyay diyaar ahaanshaha xiddiga Mohamed Salah kadib markii uu ka soo kabsaday xanuunka Korona. Xiddiga Mohamed Salah ayaa...

Stay Connected

21,080FansLike
2,452FollowersFollow
0SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles

Dhageyso : – Cabdi Farax Juxa oo ka waramaaya Taariikh nololeedkii General Khaliif Ciise Mudan

Wasiirkii hore ee Arimaha Gudaha Dawlada Fedearaalka Somaaliyeed Halgame Cabdi Farax Juxa ayaa warbaahinta uga waramay maanta Taariikh nololeedkii Allaah ha u naxariistee Generaal Khaliif Ciise Mudan oo maanta ku geeriyooday Dalka Turkey.Halkan ka dhageyso Juxa iyo Taariikh nololeedka marxuumka :

Xog: Qoor Qoor oo aqbalay dalabkii musharaxiinta balse ku xiray hal shardi

Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Linkedin Email Print Viber Muqdisho (Caasimada Online) – Madaxweynaha Maamulka Galmudug Axmed Cabdi Kaariye Qoor Qoor, ayaa kulan uu habeen hore la qaatay qaar ka mid ah musharaxiinta xilka Madaxweynaha Soomaaliya, ku ballan qaaday fulinta qodob ay cabasho ka qabeen oo ku aadan guddiyada doorashada. Sida ay ogaatay Caasimada Online, madaxweyne Qoor Qoor ayaa musharaxiinta ka aqbalay inuu badalo guddiga doorashada xubnaha ku jira qaarkood, balse waxa uu sharuud kaga dhigay in marka hore ay beddalaan maamullada kale ee dalka. “Waa naga aqbalay inuu beddalo dadka qaar ee guddiga ku jira balse waxa uu diiday inuu bilaabo isagoo naga codsaday in marka aan ka keeno maamulada kale,” ayuu yiri mid kamid ah musharaxiintii la kulmay Madaxweyne Qoor Qoor, oo la hadlay Caasimada Online. Kulankaan ayaa daba socday kulan kale oo laba habeen ka hor ka dhacay guriga Madaxweynihii hore ee Soomaaliya Xasan Sheekh Maxamuud waxaana la aaminsan yahay in Qoor Qoor dhab ka aheyn balanqaadkii uu xalay sameeyay. Shuruuddan ayaa xubnaha qaar ay ku macneeyeen mid adag, oo Qoor Qoor uga gol leeyahay inuu isaga aamuso, oo aysan daacad ka ahayn. Qoor Qoor ayaa markii la doortay, inkasta la xajinayey Villa Somalia, la rumeysnaa inuu mararka qaar yeelan doono dhiiranaan uu kaligiis go’aan ku qaato, hase yeeshee taas waxay noqotay mid lagu hungoobay. Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Linkedin Email Print Viber

Miyuu Mohamed Salah Ku Bilaaban Doonaa Kulanka Atalanta? Jurgen Klopp Ayaa Ka Jawaabay.

Tababaraha Kooxda Liverpool ee Jurgen Klopp ayaa xaqiijiyay diyaar ahaanshaha xiddiga Mohamed Salah kadib markii uu ka soo kabsaday xanuunka Korona. Xiddiga Mohamed Salah ayaa...

Ra’iisul Wasaare Rooble oo kormeeray qeybta lixdamaad iyo Dugsiga tababarka Ciidanka ee Baydhabo

Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE  Ra’iisul Wasaaraha Xukuumadda Federalka Soomaaliya Mudane Maxamed Xuseen Rooble ayaa kormeeray qeybta lixdamaad ee Ciidanka Xoogga dalka iyo Dugsiga tababarka Ciidanka Xoogga Dalka ee ay maamusho dowladda Ingiriiska. Ra’iisul Wasaaraha Soomaaliya ayaa warbixinno ku saabsan qaabka iyo noocyada tababarrada ay bixiyaan ka dhageystay saraakiisha maamusha xerada. waxuuna uga mahadceliyey taageerada ay la garab taagan yihiin dowladda, gaar ahaan dhismaha ciidamadda qaranka. Mudane Rooble ayaa kormeeray xarunta qeybta lixdamaad ee Ciidanka Xoogga dalka, isagoo warbixin ka dhageystay Taliyaha qeybta. “Ciidanka Xoogga dalka Soomaaliyeed waa naftood hurayaal u taagan difaaca dalkooda, qof walba oo Soomaaliyeed waxuu ku jiifo waa dhiigiina aad huraysaan, waaan idin leeyahay hambalyo, anaguna waan idinku garab taagannahay mar walba sidii aad dalkaan uga saari lahaydeen argagixisada”. Ra’iisul Wasaaraha ayaa kormeeray qeybaha kala duwan ee xarunta Ciidanka Xoogga dalka ee qeybta lixdanaad oo dhowaan dib-u-dhis iyo qalabayn lagu sameeyey, waxuna ku boggaadiyey saraakiishii uu kula kulmay howlaha muhiimka ah ee ay u hayaan shacabka Soomaaliyeed. Sidoo kale, Ra’iisul Wasaaraha Xukuumadda Federaalka Soomaaliya Mudane Maxamed Xuseen Rooble ayaa booqday dhaawacyada ciidanka ee ku wax yeeloobay dagaallada ay kula jiraan kooxaha argagixisada ah, isagoo Alle uga baryey inuu siiyo caafimaad. raiisul wasaraha oo kormeeray saldhig ciidan Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Linkedin LINE Previous articleShariif Xasan;”Doorasho Hal Wareeg waa diidanahay xalna kuma imanayo.”

Wasiirka Waxbarashada Koonfur Galbeed oo ka hadlay qorshaha uga degsan waxbarashada carruurta aan waxba heysan “SAWIRRO”

Share on Facebook Tweet on Twitter Wasiirka Waxbarshada Koonfur Galbeed Soomaaliya mudane Maxamed Yuusuf Xasan Waliid ayaa sheegay in mashaariic horumarineed laga hirgeliyay magaalada Baydhabo ee xarunta Gobolka Baay. Mudane Maxamed Yuusuf Xasan oo la hadlay Radio Muqdisho ayaa sheegay in mashaariicda uu shalay Ra’iisul Wasaaraha Soomaaliya Mudane Maxamed Xuseen Rooble xariga ka jaray ay qeyb ka ahayd iskuul loogu talagalay inay wax ku bartaan carruurta agoonta ah iyo kuwa waalidiintooda aysan awoodin inay geeyaan iskulaadka sida gaarka ah loo leeyahay. “Koonfur Galbeed waxa ay ka koobantahay 18 degmo, saddex ka mid ah Nabadiidka Al-Shabaab ayaa heysta, laakiin dadkii deganaa ayaa u soo guuray degmooyinka dowladdu gacanta ku heyso, waxaana noo qorsheysan in dadka soo barakacay aan u diryaarino xarumo waxbarasho oo u gaar ah”.ayuu yiri Wasiirka Waxbarashada Koonfur Galbeed. Wasiirka Waxbarashada Koonfur Galbeed Soomaaliya ayaa waalidiinta ku boooriyay inya dhiiri geliyaan waxbarashada carruurtooda oo ay siiyaan fursado ay wax ku bartaan. SHARE Facebook Twitter Previous articleMadaxweyne ku-xigeenka Hirshabeelle oo ka warbixiyay socdaalka Madxaweynaha Hirshabeelle